Free Practice Question
CR · Critical Reasoning
555-605
Weaken
Many environmental advocates support the elimination of regulations on activities deemed 'non-harmful,' which typically include practices like camping, hiking, and fishing. However, it is debatable whether fishing can truly be classified as a non-harmful activity. Beyond the ecological impact on fish populations, the practice can lead to significant distress for local communities that rely on these resources for their livelihood. For instance, those who depend on fishing for their income – local fishermen, their families, and the businesses that serve them – certainly experience hardship as they witness the depletion of fish stocks. In this context, fishing can hardly be considered a non-harmful activity.
Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument above?
Answer Choices
Correct answer marked belowA
Fishing is a recreational activity that many people enjoy without causing harm to others.
Other non-harmful activities, such as camping and hiking, can also negatively impact local ecosystems.
Correct
C
The depletion of fish stocks affects only a small number of communities.
D
Many environmental advocates believe that all regulations should be maintained to protect local economies.
E
Fishing is regulated in many areas to ensure sustainability.
See the full step-by-step explanation
You can see the correct answer above. Sign in for free to unlock the complete worked solution.
Track your performance and improve
Get detailed analytics, unlock full explanations, and move up difficulty tiers as you practice.
Explanation
Preview
Official Explanation
Official
The argument states that fishing is harmful because it causes distress to local communities that rely on fish for their livelihood. To weaken this argument, we need to show that other activities classified as non-harmful can also have negative impacts. Option 2 states that other non-harmful…
Read the full explanation
Sign in for free to see the complete step-by-step solution to this question.
Comments
3
Sign in to join the discussion
M
MuditJan 26, 2025
greatt question!
C
ChiFeb 12, 2024
thanks
A
AnjolaNov 27, 2024
thank you for sharing
What this question tests
What it tests
Whether you can identify the option that most undermines an argument's conclusion.
Common trap
Choosing an irrelevant objection or one that attacks the premise rather than the reasoning.
Related GMAT Topic Guides
Details
Difficulty
555-605
Type
CR